March 11, 2010

One Hour Blood Sugar Test is Best Predictor of Future Diabetes Risk

A study just published in the journal Diabetes Care confirms what I have suspected for a long time. The one test that gives the best indication of whether a person is in the process of developing diabetes is not the fasting glucose test used by 99% of family doctors. Nor is it the two hour value found on an oral glucose tolerance test--which has long been the gold standard endorsed by the American Diabetes Association.

What best predicts diabetes in people who are in that middle ground of not normal but not frankly diabetic is the result seen on a blood sugar test taken one hour after a glucose challenge--i.e. after eating a significant amount of carbohydrate.

You can read this study here:

Minimal Contribution of Fasting Hyperglycemia to the Incidence of Type 2 Diabetes in Subjects With Normal 2-h Plasma Glucose. Muhammad A. Abdul-Ghani. Diabetes Care March 2010 vol. 33 no. 3 557-561. doi: 10.2337/dc09-1145

In this study the researchers looked at the records of 3,450 subjects who started out with 2-hour plasma glucose concentration <140 mg/dl.[7.7 mmol/L] These subjects were participants in the San Antonio Heart Study (SAHS) and the Botnia Study for 7–8 years.

The researchers found that while incidence of type 2 diabetes at follow-up was related to the fasting, 1-h, and 2-h plasma glucose concentrations,
... when the 1-h plasma glucose, but not 2-h plasma glucose, concentration was added to the model, FPG [fasting plasma glucose] concentration was no longer a significant predictor of type 2 diabetes in both studies (NS).

When subjects were matched for the level of 1-h plasma glucose concentration, the incidence of type 2 diabetes markedly increased with the increase in 1-h plasma glucose, but the increase in FPG was not associated with a significant increase in the incidence of type 2 diabetes.
I get a lot of mail from people whose home testing is showing blood sugars well over 140 mg/dl (7.7 mmol/L) but whose doctors insist they are "fine" based on their fasting glucose readings.

If you fall into that category, and are having trouble getting your doctor to take your concerns about your blood sugar seriously, track your one hour blood sugar test results and if they are routinely over 140 mg/dl, print out this abstract and take it with you to your appointment.

You can learn how to use a blood sugar meter to test your blood here:

Am I diabetic? How to test your blood sugar to find out.

There is a less common variant of diabetes usually seen in males where the fasting blood sugar is very high but post meal blood sugar is not. If you have normal post-meal blood sugar, but see fasting blood sugars heading towards 120 mg/dl (6.7 mmol/L) you might be developing diabetes in this manner. Over time it may proceed to full fledged diabetes. Because most family doctors diagnose diabetes based on fasting tests people who develop diabetes in this pattern are more likely to have their diabetes diagnosed early.

You can read about what research has revealed about the different patterns in which diabetes develops and the likelihood of having your blood sugar dysfunction progress to diabetes HERE .

But what if your blood sugar is not going over 140 mg/dl when you eat carbohydrates? Unless your fasting blood sugar is near 120 mg/dl, you are fine. This sounds obvious, but I get a surprising amount of mail from people who have normal fasting blood sugar and normal one hour readings who are convinced there is something wrong with them. There may be, but it is usually not because they are developing diabetes.

That's because normal people's blood sugar fluctuates and may reach the upper 130s an hour after eating and then drop back to normal. The only time you might have a valid concern if your blood sugar at one hour is spiking into the 130s is if it is still in the 130s two hours after eating and even three hours after eating.

This would suggest that your body is having trouble with its second phase insulin response, which you can read about HERE. But this is rare. The most common progression to diabetes begins with one hour readings over 140 mg/dl that resolve or even produce reactive hypoglycemia. This then proceeds to readings over 140 mg/dl that stay over 140 mg/dl for another hour or two.

Though this is technically the "prediabetic range" researchers now know that the incidence of neuropathy, heart attack, and diabetic retinopathy all start to rise as one hour blood sugar goes into the range over 140 mg/dl. (More about that HERE and HERE)

If steps aren't taken to lower blood sugar when it is in the prediabetic range it may rise eventually into the official diabetic range--over 200 mg/dl. But it is very foolish to do what too many family doctors do--ignore oncoming diabetes until a person has an official diagnosis.

That's because the interventions that lower blood sugar are so much easier and more effective when you begin them when blood sugar is only modestly abnormal. When you are only seeing spikes slightly above 140 mg/dl at one hour, usually all it takes to lower blood sugar is to cut down on the amount of carbohydrate you eat at each meal.

Because blood sugars over 140 mg/dl are toxic to the beta cells that produce insulin and can, over time, kill enough of them to make you permanently diabetic, taking steps early can keep your diabetes from progressing, whatever your family history might be.

And because the most effective intervention is one that requires no prescription or help from a doctor, there is nothing to keep you from embarking on a program of healing whether or not your doctor takes your mildly abnormal blood sugars seriously.

You'll find detailed instructions for how to lower your blood sugar safely on your own here:

How to Get Your Blood Sugar Under Control

March 7, 2010

Does the Low Carb Diet Raise Cholesterol?

You may see studies that purport to prove that eating a low carb diet raises cholesterol. There was one reported in the latest edition of Diabetes in Control which you can see HERE. You may even see your cholesterol go up when you start to eat a low carb diet.

Is this reason for concern?

No. And here's why. The studies that show a rise in cholesterol are always studies of very short duration. The study reported in Diabetes in Control lasted six week. If you look at long term studies, you will see the exact opposite occur. Over time people eating low carb diets develop more favorable cholesterol profiles than those eating high carb/low fat diets.

You can see this finding documented in this metastudy published in the Nature journal, Obesity:

Cardiovascular and Hormonal Aspects of Very-Low-Carbohydrate Ketogenic Diets. Jeff S. Volek* and Matthew J. Sharman. Obesity Research (2004) 12, 115S–123S; doi: 10.1038/oby.2004.276

The very slight and short-lived rise in LDL--and it is very slight--12 mg/dl in the study described by Diabetes in control--is nothing to be afraid of. By six months into the diet it will be gone in most people, replaced by a better cholesterol profile.

The only people who may not experience this improvement are the very small number of people with diabetes who, because of some specific genetic issue, are very fat sensitive. You can tell if you are one of them because if you are, when you eat a low carb diet for six weeks your blood sugar will go up, not down. This is very rare. I have heard from two people over the past five years who experienced it.

No research has ever shown an increase in any negative health outcome from long-term adherence to a truly low carb diet--one that does not exceed 100 g per day--and trust me, they have looked for them. Because these diets are so effective in lowering blood sugar, they lower the incidence of new diabetic complications.

You can find links to many more studies proving the safety and efficacy of the low carb diet HERE. You'll also find the huge, multi-million dollar, multi-year study that proved beyond a doubt that the low fat diet, whatever its short term effect on cholesterol might be, has no effect at all on the incidence of heart disease or cancer.

Analyzing Your Cholesterol Results

If your cholesterol goes up after you start a low carb diet, it is important to understand that cholesterol is only very weakly associated with the incidence of heart disease--despite the myth promoted by the companies that sell drugs that lower total cholesterol.

Here are the measurements that actually map down to a slight rise in heart disease. To find more discussion of the studies that document this, with links, visit THIS PAGE:

1. High fasting triglycerides. If your triglycerides are over 150 mg/dl, your risk of heart disease may rise. Triglycerides are blood fats, but they rise in response to carbohydrate consumption.

2. Low HDL cholesterol. HDL the so called "good cholesterol" is protective for most people, especially when it rises to levels above 60 mg/dl. However total cholesterol is computed by adding in HDL, so it is possible to see your total cholesterol rise because your HDL has moved from a low, dangerous level to a high protective level. It is not uncommon to see people who eat long-term low carb diets develop HDL that ranges from 80 to over 100 mg/dl. This is not a problem.

3. Apo(a). This is a factor family doctors rarely measure, but it is a much more sensitive indicator of heart attack risk than cholesterol measures. If you have a family history of early heart attack, it would be a good idea to get it measured.

4. Cardiac Specific CRP. Heart disease is now understood to be an inflammatory disease that affects the arteries. The Cardiac specific CRP (C-Reactive Protein) test will tell you if your arteries are inflamed. High levels on this test suggest that you would benefit from a statin drug, because what statins actually do that prevents heart attack is NOT lower cholesterol but lower inflammation.

5. A1C Rising over 5% and Post-Meal Sugars over 153 mg/dl at 1 Hour. This is starting to look like the single strongest predictor of heart attack. Details HERE. Since lowering your carbohydrate intake is the single most powerful tool you have to lower A1c, the long term benefit of cutting carbs becomes very clear.

One Last Thing: You Don't Have to Lose Weight to Get The Benefits

Doctors often tell you that you have to lose weight to improve blood sugar and heart attack risk. While losing weight takes strain off your heart, you will get significant benefits from a diet that cuts carbohydrate even if you don't lose a single pound. That's because that kind of diet lowers blood sugar, and it is high blood sugar that is so damaging to your capillaries, nerves, retinas, and kidneys.

Many people think that to get the benefits of a low carb diet they have to eat at extremely low levels--ones many people find difficult if not impossible to sustain. However, this is not true. Many people can see impressive improvements in their health by eating at higher levels of carbohydrate intake--closer to 100 g a day, with no meal exceeding 35 g, rather than 20 g a day.

The key to health is to eat at a level that keeps your blood sugar below the levels that cause damage to your organs. Using the strategy you'll find described here, you can determine what carbohydrate intake level normalizes your blood sugar. It is different for every person:

How To Get Your Blood Sugar Under Control

If diet alone can't give you normal blood sugars, carefully chosen, safe drugs plus lowered carbohydrate intake will.

 

March 3, 2010

AMP-Kinase, Metformin and Resveratrol

AMP-kinase (AMP-k) is an enzyme which is involved in many of the processes that break down in people with Type 2 diabetes.

Wikipedia has this to say about it:
Activated by muscle contractions... It is expressed in a number of tissues, including the liver, brain, and skeletal muscle.

The net effect of AMPK activation is stimulation of hepatic fatty acid oxidation and ketogenesis, inhibition of cholesterol synthesis, lipogenesis, and triglyceride synthesis, inhibition of adipocyte lipolysis and lipogenesis, stimulation of skeletal muscle fatty acid oxidation and muscle glucose uptake, and modulation of insulin secretion by pancreatic beta-cells.
Translated into English this means that AMP-k turns on the liver's ability to burn fat and create ketones, that it lowers cholesterol and blocks the creation of fats (triglyceride) from carbohydrates, that it gets muscles burning fat and taking up glucose, and cuts back on insulin secretion.

AMP-k is partially regulated by the fat governing hormones leptin and adiponectin, hormones that are often out of control in people with Type 2 Diabetes. It has an effect on the hypothalamus which is the part of the brain that regulates appetite.

AMP-k is even more interesting when you learn that, as summarized in Wikipedia,
Under conditions of exercise, however, blood sugar levels are not necessarily high, and insulin is not necessarily activated, yet muscles are still able to bring in glucose. AMPK seems to be responsible in part for this exercise-induced glucose uptake.
Wikipedia points to THIS CITE to support that statement.

But interestingly, AMP-k expresses the most in muscles when people are not in good shape. The better trained a person is, the less AMP-k is produced.

MPK activation also produces physiological effects that appear to prevent myocardial injury during ischemia--i.e. it prevents damage to the heart muscle during a heart attack.You can read more about the technical details of how AMP-k protects the heart from heart attack in this review:

AMP-Activated Protein Kinase Conducts the Ischemic Stress Response Orchestra. Lawrence H. Young, et al. Circulation. 2008;117:832-840. doi: 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.107.713115

What makes all this very relevant to people with Type 2 diabetes is this: There is evidence that what the diabetes drug metformin really does is that it activates AMP-k. This would explain many of its known effects: that it stops weight gain and can help with weight loss, that it lowers blood sugar, that it stops the liver from dumping glucose, that it lowers cholesterol and triglyceride levels, and that it appears to lower the risk of heart attack.

Role of AMP-activated protein kinase in mechanism of metformin action Gaochao Zhou et al., J. Clin. Invest. 108(8): 1167-1174 (2001). doi:10.1172/JCI13505.

Even more insight into how metformin works is given by this review:

AMPK: Lessons from transgenic and knockout animals. Benoit Viollet et al. Front Biosci. 2009; 14: 19–44.

It is important to note that the lab findings suggest that because metformin's impact is related to its ability to raise AMP-k it does not really "reduce insulin resistance," if by that we mean that it makes cell receptors more sensitive to insulin. Instead, what it seems to do to lower blood sugars--besides keeping the liver from dumping extra glucose inappropriately--is increase the ability of the muscles to take up glucose without the need for insulin.

Because metformin is easily available and cheap, doctors tend to ignore it in favor of newer, more hyped medications. This is a shame, especially since new and highly hyped substances may turn out to merely be repeating what metformin already does. For example, a study just published this month came up with compelling evidence that the health impacts of resveratrol, the substance found in red wine that is currently the subject of much hype and misleading supplement marketing is not due to resveratrol's impact on SIRT1, as was initially speculated. Instead resveratrol's effects appear to be caused by its ability to activate AMP-k. You can read about that finding here:

AMP-Activated Protein Kinase–Deficient Mice Are Resistant to the Metabolic Effects of Resveratrol. Jee-Hyun Um et al. Diabetes March 2010 vol. 59 no. 3 554-563. doi: 10.2337/db09-0482.

Since metformin is available as a cheap generic drug and the bogus resveratrol supplements and upcoming resveratrol-derived drugs are, or will be, extremely expensive, all this suggests metformin is probably an excellent, safe way to get whatever benefits are attributed to resveratrol.

However, in the course of my reading about AMP-k I learned a few other things which may point to some additional strategies that could help those of us who take metformin. One major finding is that in a natural state AMP-k gets produced in response to various stresses. It is not normally at high levels all the time which may be what happens when we take a drug that keeps it activated.

When AMP-k is kept "on" continuously, there are subtle hints that it may cause some bad things may happen. These studies point to this possibility--though I caution you not to overreact to these findings:

Diverse Cytopathologies in Mitochondrial Disease Are Caused by AMP-activated Protein Kinase Signaling Paul B. Bokko et al. MBoC March 1, 2007. doi/10.1091/mbc.E06-09-0881

Over-expression of AMP-activated protein kinase impairs pancreatic ß-cell function in vivo S K Richards, et al. Journal of Endocrinology (2005) 187, 225-235 DOI: 10.1677/joe.1.06413

Fortunately, another study suggests that the concentrations of metformin achieved by people who take the drug are "suboptimal" as far as raising AMP-k which might help prevent negative outcomes from taking it.

The Antidiabetic Drug Metformin Activates the AMP-Activated Protein Kinase Cascade via an Adenine Nucleotide-Independent Mechanism Simon A. Hawley et al. Diabetes August 2002 vol. 51 no. 8 2420-2425.doi: 10.2337/diabetes.51.8.2420

The long term data on the health of people taking metformin which has been in use for many decades is very good. They appear to have lower rates of heart attack and less cancer as well as slightly better blood sugars and better weight than those taking other competing drugs for insulin resistance or insulin deficiency.

However, the fact that AMP-k levels drop in people as they become more physically trained and hints that there may be problems with keeping an enzyme that naturally fluctuates at higher levels all the time got me thinking. I have found that with some other drugs, that taking a "drug holiday" now and then, which means stopping the drug for a week and then going back on it, gives me much better results than taking the drug all the time. This is particularly true for hormone supplements like estrogen which fluctuate in a natural state.

I had also noticed that metformin seemed to have much more impact on weight and even blood sugar the first few months after it is started. So for the past few months I have been experimenting with cycling off Metformin for a week every month and then going back on it. My doctor had assured me years ago that metformin is a drug that can be started and stopped without any negative effect.

Since I am a sample of one and have some very odd metabolic issues not common to most people with diabetes, my experience probably isn't relevant to others, though subjectively I do seem to be getting more impact out of metformin taking this way. It is worth experimenting with this if you are a person who had a strong response to metformin when you started it, only to see it wear off. In that case, it might be worth trying a cycling approach for a month or two to see if it helps.

My personal experience is that when I start metformin again I also get day or two of gastrointestinal symptoms characteristic of the drug. If this is a problem for you, you might not want to try the experiment.

Note: There are SOME drugs that are dangerous if you start them and then stop them without a doctor's help. Do not take a drug holiday from any drug without discussing the issue with a registered pharmacist. Pharmacists are much better informed about drug behavior and safety than are most doctors. Just make sure if you are in a pharmacy that you speak to a registered pharmacist, not an assistant, as the assistants do not have the training you need to get a good answer to this kind of question.

 

February 27, 2010

Brand New Gestational Diabetes Cutoffs Point to Safe Levels

The cutoffs for diagnosing gestational diabetes--the kind that occurs during pregnancy--have always been more stringent than those used to diagnose the general population. Now a large study that matched maternal blood sugars with the outcome of the pregnancy has documented that even more stringent blood sugar limits are necessary to avoid diabetic problems during pregnancy.

Not so surprisingly, the new blood sugar targets they urge are very similar to those that are emerging from research connecting blood sugar levels with complications with diabetes in people who are NOT pregnant. (Details HERE.)

Here, from the report in Science Daily are the findings:
Based on a study of more than 23,000 women in nine countries, Metzger and an international group of 50 experts concluded a fasting blood sugar level of 92 or higher, a one-hour level of 180 or higher on a glucose tolerance test or a two-hour level of 153 or higher on a glucose tolerance test constitute serious risks to the mother and baby.
Science Daily: Gestational Diabetes: Blood Sugar Levels Once Considered Normal Are Not Safe for Baby, Mother

Compare these findings to the results in non-pregnant people that found that the presence in young men of a fasting blood sugar over 92 mg/dl predicted the development of diabetes a decade later, and that cardiovascular risk takes a major step up once the one hour glucose tolerance test result goes over 155. (Details HERE.)

Since complications kick in at these levels you would want to keep your blood sugar a bit lower, which is why I continue to suggest that you shoot for the "Five Percent Club" blood sugar targets. Note that the fasting number in our targets is higher, largely because so many people with diabetes will find the fasting number the hardest to lower. Most research, however, points to the post-meal numbers as being those that produce the complications.

The values before are for first thing in the morning fasting blood sugar and one and two hours after eating meals.

February 18, 2010

Yes: Actos and Avandia Cause a Huge Increase in Fracture Risk

I've blogged about the way Avandia and Actos cause osteoporosis and broken bones before. I've also documented this on the page where I summarize all the research that makes it clear how dangerous both these drugs are, which you can read HERE.

But I wanted to bring your attention to a new cohort study involving 19,070 patients with diabetes, which was published in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism. It quantifies just how big the fracture risk of these drugs really is.

Thiazolidinedione Use and the Longitudinal Risk of Fractures in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus Zeina A. Habib et al. JClinEndo&Metab Vol. 95, No. 2 592-600 doi:10.1210/jc.2009-1385

As summarized in the newsletter, Endocrine Today, researchers
... studied 19,070 patients at Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit between January 2000 and May 2007. The study group included 9,620 women and 9,450 men.

During the study period, 4,511 patients had at least one prescription filled for a TZD. The investigators used electronically maintained medical claims data to identify nontraumatic bone fractures.

TZD use was associated with an increased risk for fracture in the overall cohort (adjusted HR=1.35; 95% CI, 1.05-1.71) and in women (HR=1.57; 95% CI, 1.16-2.14). Men, regardless of age, were not at an increased risk for fractures (HR=1.05; 95% CI, 0.70-1.58).

Women aged 65 years and older appeared to be at the greatest risk for fracture (HR=1.72; 95% CI, 1.17-2.52).

They found that the increased risk for fracture in women appeared after approximately one year of TZD use.
Before you conclude that this means this is a safe drug for men and younger women, you need to remember that fractures due to osteoporosis only occur after bone has been significantly weakened. Older women already have weak bones so any factor that weakens them further will stand out.

But the chances are very good that these drugs are causing osteoporotic changes in patients with denser bones and that over time they too will find themselves with dangerously fragile bones.

The reason we know this is that we know WHY these drugs cause osteoporosis. It is because the mechanism they use transforms stems cells that would normally become baby bone cells into baby fat cells. You can read more about this mechanism HERE.

With what we already know about how these drugs cause edema and promote heart failure in people who did not have it before they started the drug this latest very large study should make it crystal clear that this is not a good drug to take. Once you've rotted out your long bones, you face a lifetime of limited mobility that undoes any minor change in blood sugar they may make. And they only make a very small change in blood sugar. Not enough to take this kind of risk.

If your doctor still insists this is a safe drug, print out the information you'll find HERE and for an explanation of why you should be ignoring it.